A couple of readers have asked for some information on protein shakes and powders so I thought I’d do full post on them. I’m no expert, so this information is based on what I’ve picked up over the last couple of years from books, websites and blogs, and my own experiences of course! If you been reading the blog for a while you will see that I use protein powders in my diet quite often in various forms such as in smoothies, with porridge, mixed into yoghurt, in muffins, pancakes, cakes or even just straight up mixed with water or milk as a shake or goo.
Why is protein important?
- Keeps you fuller for longer and therefore supports weight loss and weight maintenance
- Supports the building of muscles / preserves muscle mass. This is especially important when dieting to make sure that you lose fat rather than lean muscle
- Helps the body to repair – protein supports tissue repair which is important for recovery after working out, as well as having healthy skin, hair and nails
- Important if you are wanting to develop a more ’toned’ look (however, you can not ‘tone’ a muscle, you can only make a muscle larger, which will result in the sculpted ‘toned’ look) as protein helps to build the muscles
Which foods are rich in protein?
- Diary – cottage cheese, yoghurt, milk, cheese
- Eggs – particually egg whites
- Meat and Poultry – chicken and turkey are my faves
- Fish and seafood
- Soy based products – tofu, quorn etc
- Beans and legumes – lentils, kidney beans etc
So why use protein powders then?
- Convenience – using protein powders can be a more convenient way of increasing your protein intake rather than eating protein rich foods.
- Effectiveness – the protein in some suppliments is in a form which is easier for the body to use than other food based proteins
- Flavours – many protein powders come in various tasty flavours. This can help to control cravings when dieting or maintaining weight
- As a useful ingredient in various recipes - protein powders can be used in cooking to make healthier treats or to add more flavour to smoothies etc
Will using protein powders make me too bulky?
Protein powders – some of the varieties
- Whey - Whey is a bi product of the production of various dairy products. You can get a couple of different types of whey, whey isolate and whey concentrate, or a product which is a mix of the two.
- Soy – Protein powders can also be made with soy products for those that prefer to avoid any diary products (although most lactose intollerant people are ok with the very low levels of lactose present in whey protein) and those that follow a vegan diet)
- Pea / Hemp etc – There are loads of other kinds of protein powders that are derived from all sorts of different protein sources such as pea, hemp, rice, egg etc
Unfortunately most protein powders are highly proccessed products (the ones that aren’t are a lot more expensive) and often contain artifical sweeteners etc. I usually like to eat a diet that is as free from processed food as possible, protein powders are pretty much the one thing that I eat on a regular basis that is processed as I believe the benefits outweigh the negatives within my individual diet.
Over the last few months I have tried out a couple of different brands of protein powders and in my experience all of these have been very good products (Obviously I am writing this from a UK perspective, and can only provide my views on the products I have actually sampled) -
My Protein – this website has an almost mind boggling selection of protein products. So far I have tried the True Whey which comes in a huge 5lb drum and in my opinion, is good value for money. I have tried this in the chocolate and vanilla flavours (I find that these make good flavour bases to be used in different meals and recipes as they can be combined with different ingredients with complementary flavours). I have tried these as a shake made with water which tasted ok, a shake made with milk which tastes better, but my favourite way to use this product is in smoothies, porridge, mixed with yoghurt, to make protein pancakes and simply mixed with a little milk to make a protein goo desert. I have just purchased some samples of the Impact Whey Blend and some other flavours of the True Whey which I will review when I try them. Ordering from My Protein is very good, their delivery options are next day and only cost £3.95.
Maximuscle / Maxitone - Again, Maximuscle offer a large range of protein products. The Maxitone website is aimed at women and the Maximuscle site for men (but don’t be put off visiting it as well, many of the same products have just been repackaged in a more female friendly way on the Maxitone site). I have tried Promax Diet, Promax Natural and Sculptress (which as far as I can tell is the Promax Diet repackaged). I just used the Promax Diet and Sculptress mixed with water as a shake when I was really focusing on getting my weight down. These products contain additional ingredients to support weight loss such as added caffeine. I certainly lost weight while using these shakes and they kept me really full. They tasted ok as well. I really liked the Promax Natural as this could be mixed with smoothies and porridge without affecting the taste and just adding extra creaminess. These products are quite expensive, but in my experience pretty good quality.
Spiru-tein – The other product I have used is Spiru-tein. I was initally attracted to this product due to all the fab flavours they have available such as chocolate peanut butter and cherries jubilee. Spiru-tein contains a mix of soy, pea and rice proteins, although they do have some powders that are derived from whey. They also contain a number of vitamins and the green superfood spirulina. I used to use this mixed with milk as a desert after dinner. I have just purchased more and will review how I use it as I go. I have read on various blogs that soy based protein products work much better than whey products in cooking and baking so I’m looking forward to giving that a try! I purchase Spirutein from this website based in the UK.
When to use protein powders
- Post workout – especially a weight lifting workout, to support recovery and muscle repair
- Evening / before bed – the body repairs itself while you sleep, protein will support this
- To help keep you full when cravings strike
- To make lower fat and calorie treats
Recipe Ideas
Chocolate Cherry Green Monster
1 scoop of chocolate protein powder
Frozen Cherries
Big handful of spinach
Milk (I like using rice milk)
Blend till smooth and serve in a large glass or bowl
Protein Pancakes
1 scoop of protein powder of your choice
3 egg whites
1 tablespoon of apple sauce
1/2 teaspoon of baking powder
I hope you have found this post useful. Please remember that I’m no expert and that all of this is based on my own personal experiences. I believe our bodies are all different – I seem to respond to protein very well but I know that protein powders aren’t for everyone. I really enjoy the variety that protein powders bring to my diet in terms of flavour and taste and the fact that they help me stay fuller for longer to prevent me snacking on other unhealthy foods, as well as supporting my muscle growth. Do you use protein powders in your diet? What has been your experiences with them? How do you use them?
I’ll be back tomorrow with today’s eats, and they have been tasty again! Hope you have all had a good weekend, catch you tomorrow x
{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }
Protein powders get so confusing. I hate going to the store and seeing entire walls of the containers; there are so many different kinds. Did you see the consumer reports article that found metals in some powders?
Katherine
Great post hun, really interesting. I’m currently using Whey isolate from My Protein in milk or water shakes and occasionally smoothies or soft serve
Good post :o)
I’m a MyProtein fan since I had lots of stomach problems related to Maxismuscle products that I tested to be sure it was that and not anything else. I certainly use protein supplements after working out, mixed with skimmed milk is delicious. This weekend I made a frappuccino with it for the first time and it was -so- much nicer than the ones you get in the shops, less sickly sweet and much creamier. Also I have some in my breakfast, mixed in with greek yogurt and fruit in some form or other.
No idea if it’s helping or not, as I’ve only ever used it since I started gymming just over a year ago and the results have been great, but that might just be the weight training ;o)
I’m experimenting with CLA supplement at the moment as it’s supposed to help aid fat loss when you’re training hard. I’ll see what the results look like in a month’s time!
I take mine like a shot, means to an end , so basically a runnier version of your goo.
I totally agree on the artificial sweetner aspect thats why I rarely have it. I saw natural whey do one but its on in the big tubs and I’d rather try a sachet first before committing to £35
Brilliant post – I am just starting to use protein powders for the first time so that’s really useful.
This post is a great help Laura. The protein world is very confusing, but I am swayed by the Spiru-tein brand and I’ve also been looking at Fruit-ein too. Thank you for your help!
This is really useful, I wanted to try some protein powder but, like you, I try my best to avoid anything processed and was really worried about the ingredients. I think I might try Maxitone though. Thanks for the help!